Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Wort Hog Competition April 2015 BJCP 16E

Below are the scores for the beer at the WortHog competition September meeting.  Past Brews: #110 Affligem Noel

JudgeAppearance
(15%)
(0-3 points)
Aroma
(20%)
(0-4 points)
Taste
(50%)
(0-10 points)
Overall Impression
(15%)
(1-3 points)
TotalNotes
Chad
3
2
4
1
10
Good Clarity
Nice Head
Strong Alcohol nose, strong phentenol
ripe banana
strong clove
good mouthfeel
spice character
Lindsay
2
1
7
1
11

Henry
2
3
5
2
12
Dark copper, clear, some head
Sweat, caramel, slightly phenelic
Slightly under attenuated
Let it ferment out
David Tudy
2
2
6
2
12
Deep amber
Aroma: some ???/alcohol.  Malty aroma some cinnamon spice
Alcohol warmth, slightly astringency in the finish
Lacking balance
Nick Pagano
2
2
7
3
14
head retention moderate holds lace around edge, ruby red amber appearance
Carbonation well holds to lace
Aroma: malty sweetness of cherry, apricot, and slight fig
Taste: Malty, cherry, apricot, fig aligned with nose, well rounded, sweetness emerges out of fruit esters, tsty bread notes

Lower score due to some belgian off notes
Brent
3
2
7
2
14
Looks nice.
Aroma: Sweet with something harsh
very malty.  Good beer.  Hard to judge
Jason B
3
3
6.5
2
14.5
Super malty, sweet
Spicy phenlic
Malty, spicy,, good beer
No faults
Good but hard to judge
Strong, malty flavors, good carb
Jason G
2
3
7.5
2
14.5

Bob
2
3
8
2
15
Unique flavors almost with churria?
Rob B
3
3
7
2
16

Ding Diny?
3
2
7
2
15
very malty
A bit sweet with good esters
Interesting!!
Erin
3
3
7
2
15
Great clarity
Bananas
Alcohol hot finish
It's difficult to score since guidelines are variable.  A bit too much alcohol burn on the back end and not a lot of front end flavor.
^el
3
2.5
7
2.5
15
My memory of Noels is that they should be a little spicier - don't get a lot of spice
Judith Leggett
3
4
7
2
16
Aroma is nicely in style
Taste is a bit disjointed
Tim
2.5
3
8
2.5
16
Really interesting - at first I thought the alcohol was a bit harsh but then I realized it is due to either the yeast or full mouthfeel
Stuart Macrae
3
3
9
2
17
Nice
Jym Ferrier
3
4
8
2
17
Little light
While
3
3
9
3
18
Great Job
Robert P
2.5
3.5
9
3
18
Very good color and aroma
??
Glen? R
3
4
9
3
19
Awesome!  The aroma is so potent and every not is perfect.  I'd love this in a sniffer.  The body is just a touch fizzy, and I'd have liked a touch less sweetness and a touch more stone? fruit, but a very impressive brewing achievement!
Nick Leggett
3
4
9
3
19
Excellent Beer.  Congratulations!
C Frye
3
4
9.5
3
19.5
Very nice
Wendell
3
4
10
3
20
Excellent!  Malt, spice, yeast flavor/aroma all in balance.  Could be a little higher carbonated.
If high alcohol, very sneaky, does not show high ABV
Rob F
3
4
10
3
20
Beautiful
Average
2.71
3
7.65
2.29
15.72
Rated as a good beer. 
Reviews were mixed

No comments:

Post a Comment

linkwithin_site_id 2127225

Related Posts Plugin...