Wednesday, September 9, 2015

Competition Results from Open Choice - 14C Imperial IPA

Below are the scores for the beer at the WortHog competition September meeting.
The beer judged was Past Brews: #131 The Plinian Legacy.

JudgeAppearance
(15%)
(0-3 points)
Aroma
(20%)
(0-4 points)
Taste
(50%)
(0-10 points)
Overall Impression
(15%)
(1-3 points)
TotalNotes
David H
2
1.5
5
1.5
10
This beer has great potential knowing it needs more time on hops.  Will be a 14-15, but my top score was 12
Brent
3
3
6
2
13
Copper color, nice head, hazy.  Hop aroma
Not sure how much I like the hop aroma
Odd citus medicini blend
Lemony citus flavors
Overall a solid beer
Jason G
2.5
3
6
2
13.5
Green Taste
Cloudy - dry hopped
Jason B
1.5
2
7
2
13.5
Hazy - a little is ok, but too much
Some hops, some plastic
Nice hop bitterness
Lingering bitterness, but not harsh
good carb, decent body
For style, needs more dry hop and some more late hop flavor
Good attenuation
Adaene??
3
2
8
1
14
Grapefruit aroma, pretty color, bery bitter
Strong grapefruit flavor
Erin
3
4
7
2
16
Hate to say it but very nice beer.  I'm not a hop fan
Luke
2
4
8
2
16
Not a IPA fan.  Well done by style
Josh Feltz
2
3
9
2
16
Great balance of malt and hop
Best I've had so far
Slight melon note at end
Ian N
2
3
10
2
17
Good representation of the style, a little cloudy and not enough head
Jason k Jones
2
4
9
2
17
Cloudy, nice head
Big citrus, slight maltiness
Needs a little more malt to balance
Clean, crips bitterness
Could use some more hop aroma, but needs lots more flavor hops
David Tuchey
3
3
8
3
17
Off white head
Cloudy
Golden color
Aroma: Strong citrus aroma
Flavor: Strong hop flavor followed by strong hop bitterness.  You hit this style
This is a one beer beer
Clint
2
4
9
2
17
Decent off white hed.  Pretty hzy.  Lower head due to higher alcohol.  Nice hop aroma- Citra?  Good carbonation.  Nicely bitter.  I'd like more hop flavor.  Pretty well balanced
Romano
3
4
8
2
17
Color golden.  ostly clear
Smell the hops!
Can't taste the hops
All bitter some malt
Really tasty
Personally if you can get some hop flavor in the taste this would work on all levels
Matt M
2
4
9.5
2.5
18
Would like a little more bitterness on the finish
S: Good aroma, hoppy rassy, somre fruitiness, fresh and some alcohol sweattness
A: Good head, slightly cloudy, but ok
F: Great hop flavor, nice finish, some good malty sweatness, could use more back end bitterness.  Slightly drying finish, good makes me want another sip
Glen
3
3
9
3
18

Rob F
2.5
4
9
3
18.5
Good head, a bit excessively cloudy
Hop bitterness and flavor very different from aroma
Cathy Frye
3
3.5
10
3
19.5
Very to style.  Interesting in that the aroma (sweet-citrus) of hops is different from the taste (bitter).
Average
2.44
3.24
8.09
2.18
15.94
Rated as a good beer. 
Definitively room for improvement

No comments:

Post a Comment

linkwithin_site_id 2127225

Related Posts Plugin...